The Hanoi People's Court on Wednesday began trying Than, 76, also former chairman and general director of developer Bemes, for deceiving customers.
The trial is expected to last 13 days, seven years after a criminal case was opened against him. It follows eight rounds of additional investigation and an earlier trial that sent the case back for further investigation.
![]() |
| Le Thanh Than goes to court in Hanoi, Nov. 18, 2026. Photo by VnExpress/The Bang |
Le Duc Phuong, 68, was among the first victims to arrive at court. He was also among the first residents to move into the CT6 Kien Hung building in Kien Hung Ward.
Phuong said the project was so sought-after in 2011 that buyers needed a personal introduction or a special allocation to secure an apartment.
His family of six had shared one home for years, and as his children married, they needed more space. Phuong and his wife, both university lecturers, paid nearly VND1.5 billion (US$58,000), or VND21 million per square meter, for a 73-square-meter apartment on the fourth floor.
Like the other buyers, Phuong wants a secure place to live, ideally with an ownership certificate for his apartment. If he cannot stay, he hopes to receive compensation based on market prices.
Without ownership certificates, the 519 buyers cannot register their apartments as legally recognized property in their names. This limits their ability to sell or mortgage the homes through ordinary property transactions. Although certain purchase-contract transfers may be allowed under specific legal conditions, buyers cannot simply trade the apartments as registered owners. Inheritance is also complicated: heirs may inherit valid contractual rights or claims, but cannot automatically inherit a registered ownership title that has never been issued.
Five former local officials are standing trial alongside Than: Do Van Hung, former chairman of Ha Dong District's Kien Hung Ward; Nguyen Duy Uyen and Bui Van Bang, former vice chairmen of the ward; Nguyen Van Nam, former chief construction inspector of the former Ha Dong District; and his former deputy, Vuong Dang Quan. All five face charges of negligence causing serious consequences.
The project's master plan was approved by the then Ha Tay Province in June 2008. Bemes, Than's company, was the developer.
The approved design called for two buildings with 690 apartments and hotel rooms.
During construction, Bemes expanded the building footprints, added floors, changed the buildings' functions and erected a third tower.
Prosecutors said the project ultimately had 1,582 apartments, far exceeding the approved plan. Construction was completed in November 2012, and buyers began moving in two months later.
From March 2011, Than allegedly directed the project to be advertised as fully approved and sold apartments at prices that included the cost of ownership certificates, leading buyers to believe their ownership would be legally recognized.
Because of the construction violations, authorities issued certificates for only 918 apartments and 19 low-rise houses. The remaining 519 buyers are recognized as victims in the case.
Prosecutors said the VND531.8 billion (US$20.5 million) paid by these buyers represented the developer's illicit gains and the damage caused.
The indictment also said unauthorized construction went unchecked, allowing the violations to continue. This is why the five former officials and construction inspectors are facing trial.
Relocation order
The additional apartments have increased pressure on the project's supporting infrastructure.
Under a Nov. 17 decision by Hanoi government on CT6 Kien Hung, 1,458 apartments on floors four to 32 of the CT6A, CT6B and CT6C towers may remain, subject to conditions. Another 125 apartments on the second and third floors must be vacated so the space can be restored to its approved public or other designated uses. Ten low-rise houses must also be demolished, while 28 others may remain subject to renovation and urban improvements.
The decision does not amount to a blanket confirmation that the buildings have passed all safety inspections. Their continued use is conditional on maintaining structural safety, fire prevention and firefighting, and rescue requirements, as well as completing infrastructure upgrades.
The developer must also restore the planned kindergarten, maintain parking facilities and expand community space. The project currently has about 400 square meters of community space, compared with the required 1,167 square meters for the 1,458 apartments allowed to remain. At least another 767 square meters must be provided.
Electricity and water systems must operate normally. If they cannot meet demand, the developer must work with utility providers to upgrade them. The project must also restore sections of internal roads and provide the required technical and social infrastructure.
At his 2023 trial, Than disputed the allegation that the project violated its master plan, arguing that only the buildings' functions had changed, not their structures. He also challenged the calculation of damages, saying Bemes had incurred substantial costs for land-use fees, acquiring the project, materials and construction.
On civil liability, the indictment said Bemes had negotiated to buy back 39 apartments in the CT6C building to reduce losses for customers. In a further development, BIDV said in an April 24 letter that it had committed to providing Bemes with a VND1 trillion credit line to fund compensation.
Hanoi has approved a special mechanism to address violations at 12 projects linked to Muong Thanh Group. The projects will be assessed based on planning compliance, structural safety, fire prevention and firefighting, and infrastructure requirements.
Across the 12 projects, Hanoi found that the approved plans or permits covered 6,759 apartments, while 24,943 had actually been built, an excess of 18,184 units. The additional population has put pressure on local technical and social infrastructure.
Under the city's mechanism, developers must pay for compensation, relocation, demolition and remedial work. Residents required to move are entitled to compensation, while those allowed to remain can continue under their existing contracts without bearing the cost of correcting the developers' violations.